Skip to main content

Harry Partridge Snubs GoAnimate

Independent British Film Maker, Harry Partridge has taken a no holds barred swipe at GoAnimate with his animation, GoAnimate! An Animation Revolution which he posted on Youtube and Newgrounds. Inevitably it was posted to industry blog, Cartoon Brew, for comment. You can watch his animation embeded below.



I found Harry's animation humorous and over the top. I do understand his point of view if you team it up with his animations description, reproduced below.

For the record I am indifferent to the software. I have no problem with people wanting to create animation with it for fun as long as those with loftier ambitions aren't letting their skills stagnate. I spent a lot of time with 3D movie maker as a kid because I didn't know how else I could create animation and I really wish I had discovered flash sooner. Brad Bird began his first animated film at 11 years old so you're never too young to start!

So please remember that my animated counterpart is a caricature in more ways than one; I didn't really jump on a horse when Skyrim was announced and I'm not about to go postal on someone who wants to use some gimmicky animation software, just consider the alternatives.

- Harry Partridge

What is surprising is the amount of borderline, venomous and trollish comments against GoAnimate by so called purist animators or animation fans - it's hard to tell how many of the commenter's actually do create any kind of animation.

You can read the comments on Harry's Youtube posting to get a sample of what I mean. Similar comments also appear on the video on Newgrounds and even more surprisingly, Cartoon Brew.

I haven't weighed into the discussion on these sites too much because I feel many of the people reacting negatively to GoAnimate have very closed minds and aren't really open to having their perception of GoAnimate changed from their limited experience of the site.

I did, however leave the following comment on Cartoon Brew:

I've read so many negative comments towards GoAnimate from so called animation 'purists' in support of Harry's video that I'd be embarrassed to stand along side any of you and support what you do.

Any real animator would recognise GoAnimate as just another tool and just another way to create an animation (and YES it IS animation). All those characters on GoAnimate were animated by talented animators so that people could use them to create their own stories, music videos, jokes, social commentary, series etc. etc.

Sure kids can use GoAnimate to create animations. Just like kids can pick up a pencil and draw animations frame by frame. It's not about the tool, it's about who uses the tool and how far they can push it to it's potential.

Most of you bagging GoAnimate have barely spent any time with it to really know what it can do. Most of you don't even realize you can use real voice actors and you can make the drag and drop characters seem less wooden if that's what you want to do.

There are people on GoAnimate who spend months on their animations to create something entertaining and worth while. It's not all quick, easy and poorly conceived. Look a little deeper and see what it's really about.

You all eventually embraced Flash because you realized it could get your work done easier and quicker than you used to make it. GoAnimate is the same. In the right hands it can get an idea animated easier and quicker than you might otherwise. Sure you wouldn't use it to make a feature film but to get down a quick idea that you never intended to take to a full drawn animation... you might use it for that.

-TET

I also made my own video response to Harry's video, which is getting similar negative comments about GoAnimate. My video is embeded below. I included Harry's clip in full as part of the video so that more people on GoAnimate would see it - I really think that is what Harry would have wanted.



I've been accussed of not putting any time or thought into this video by commenters who really have no clue about what it takes to make a GoAnimate video.

Excluding all my research (i.e. reading all the feedback Harry's Video has been getting on all the sites mentioned) I spent a good five hours creating my response. I know that's probably nothing compared to the time Harry put into his original video but it's hardly 'quick, easy and ill conceived' either.

First off, I know the animation in my response is not impressive to anyone with any real skill at hand drawn animation (including myself). I could have done a lot to make this better with a few custom mods of my own. I could have got rid of the canned computer voices and invited the featured GoAnimators to voice their characters (heck the main character is me. I could've done my own voice). However Harry is protesting against drag'n'drop, lifeless animation so I wanted to make this as much like the very thing being protested as possible.

The main threat that GoAnimate presents to 'traditional' flash animators online is speed. The animation doesn't need to be great it just needs to be responsive and have dialogue that resonates with the intended audience. The quicker you can respond to a trending viral topic the more you can take advantage of that audience before it fades and moves on.

This is how sites like GoAnimate and Xtranormal are being used by content creators like Tiny Watch Productions who have capitalized on the success of their original Xtranormal Video iPhone4 Vs HTC Evo (12,966,608 views to date).

That is why my response to Harry focused on speed. There is in fact a market for this type of quick, animated video. The internet's attention span is short and many people won't read a long blog post like this, but put some humorous, sharp, satirical comedy into a mediocre animation and people will watch regardless. Not only that but they'll share it around too.

The times are changing for animation and Youtube knows it. That's one reason why they've partnered with both GoAnimate and Xtranormal. Both sites do what Youtube does - empowers anyone to make video and find an audience.

Moving on to the Family Guy references in my response. The same people reacting negatively to GoAnimate also seem to dislike Family Guy (and other animated shows from the same production team). Obviously the Comedy World theme (used in my response) is not only influenced by Family Guy it blatantly copies its look and style from it.

GoAnimate is more than just one theme. GoAnimations can look nothing like Family Guy if you choose a different theme but what better way to irritate detractors more than to use that theme (plus it's my favorite GoAnimate theme).

Finally I put my version of Harry Partridge into the clip because it provides a good contrast to the 'Lazy' GoAnimators on the couch (another reference to the detractors who think GoAnimators are lazy). For the record it took me a good 45 minutes to try and get Harry's likeness using GoAnimate's Comedy World Character Creator. Harry definitely didn't use GoAnimate to create his GoAnimate likeness in his clip. Few of the facial features he used exist in that form on GoAnimate

I'd be very surprised if Harry ever makes a direct, animated video response - or even a part two. Why would he invest that kind of time in something he's already covered so well?

What would be really cool is if he took a closer look at GoAnimate and recognised how it might enable him to be more prolific. I'm sure he has plenty of ideas that might stand a chance of being realised via GoAnimate that wouldn't get beyond an idea otherwise.

The Bottom Line

At the time of writing, by GoAnimate's own stats, they claim to have over one million members. That's a lot of people who quite possibly found the site because they had an interest in animation.

It is beyond me how professional flash animators can bag the site so much without realising the potential audience it creates for their work (especially independent animators like Harry).

Many of GoAnimate's members are under 20 years of age (and even under 10 years) and really appreciate good work when they see it.

GoAnimate handles Flash imports fairly well. Rather than bagging the site these animators could embrace it with their custom work and really inspire people to look beyond the site at where they could progress to.

GoAnimate is a great starting point for animators who are looking for a career in the field. Especially an indy career like Harry's. Serious GoAnimators conceive almost every part of their animation, script, direction, storyboarding, editing, sound, music, visuals etc. Many even add their own graphical customizations that range from simply importing an image to completely creating their own animated flash characters, props and backgrounds from scratch.

The few professional animators who do use the site are doing some really great work with it and encouraging people to look beyond and discover Flash - because even on GoAnimate, people know that you need Flash Animation software to do the really cool animation.

Harry isn't actually telling most GoAnimators anything they didn't already know.

Comments

  1. Harry's only out to prove that quality requires time and effort, something you didn't put in your response, relatively speaking. 5 hours is the amount of time you should have spent creating your characters alone, not the entire thing. Yes, it may take longer, but as you've seen with any game or movie, people would rather WAIT for something made with quality rather than something botched and speedily made.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Anonymous - not really. If you listen to what Harry's animation is saying, and team that with his own words about his animation, what he was attempting to do was highlight the freedom of expression contained in learning to animate from scratch. He actually says very little about the time and effort required and the quality produced.

    If you've read this blog post then you should have worked out that my animation demonstrates the role canned animation can play (and is playing) when a quick response is desired where quality isn't really important or budget doesn't allow for quality.

    And...

    My animation is deliberately designed the way it is to push the buttons of detractors such as yourself. If you think it's bad and feel a need to tell me then it has succeeded.

    I did not claim this animation to be a 'troll' after the fact just because people disliked it. I fully expected people to dislike any response made with GoAnimate that was submitted as a response to Harry's video - so I gave those people everything they said they disliked about GoAnimate (right down to actually mentioning Family Guy) so they could say "See - I told you it was shit and this proves it".

    Thanks to those people and their enthusiastic dislike of my video I was able to fast track my TETanimations channel for revenue share. I'm not upset at the response. I've had a lot of fun baiting people in the comments on my video into thinking I actually care about their opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  3. GoAnimate is made so people who can't animate can call themselves animators. It's like picking up a guitar, playing a recording, and claiming your good at guitar.

    He's probably annoyed at it's stand of "change the way animation works". In all honesty it won't the program is horrible, as why no actual professionals use it nor support it. Even if Harry seemed "immature" or "trolly" against GoAnimate, his point still stands. I support him on that.

    Harry puts forth time and effort, giving him quality animations, not any effortless trash made with GoAnimate made to get attention. Just stop.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I disagree, GoAnimate is made so people who can't animate can make their own cartoons. That said a lot of animation done in GoAnimate is done in exactly the same way as you'd do it in flash - the principles are the same.

      GoAnimate will have little to no influence on top end animation but it will erode the bottom end of the market for professional animators... which is in corporate animation such as product presentations etc. Professional animators in this field will either have to drop their prices to compete or start offering GoAnimate Toons as an additional service.

      Chances are you missed Harry's point (as most people do) just like you missed that I said actual professionals do use and support GoAnimate. You're ill informed on so many levels.

      Delete
  4. I personally love that you disabled comments on your video, but the dislike bar should speak to itself. You have gotten very, very few likes and a few thousand dislikes, so your point should seem invalid at this point. People will always prefer the animation that someone put time into, instead of the shitty GoAnimate productions, hence why Harry has 83 million views and 350,000 subscribers, while you all have less than 150,000 views and 250 subscribers. Also notice, you may have 5 times as many videos, but still no one cares about your animations. Harry Partridge is an incredibly talented animator while on the other hand you could just be some teenager with little to no talent just making crap animations. But most likely you'll ignore everything I've said and just keep on wasting time making things no one will see.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I disabled the comments on my video because I felt 8 months of responding to comments very similar to yours was really quite enough time devoted to the video. Especially when the intended audience, such as yourself, fail to understand that the dislikes my video received is a reinforcement of the success of my intentions in creating it in the first place. You aren't supposed to like it and I deliberately loaded it with things GoAnimate haters would dislike.

      As for the view comparison, my Youtube channel is really just an archive of animations. I don't actively promote it since the audience for GoAnimations is on GoAnimate's own web site - where I have over 11,000 fans (sure, not as many as Harry but not exactly 'no one' either - and this blog gets thousands of views per month).

      I could be some teenager with little or no talent... but I'm not. If you're so incompetent that you can't click on the 'About TET' menu item at the top of the page why shouldn't I ignore you... it's more likely your just some teenager with little or no talent and no ability to research, think or have an original thing to say about Harry's or my video. People with real opinions generally don't post anonymously.

      Delete
  5. Replies
    1. I don't need to imagine, it was good. I had a great time with it.

      Delete

Post a Comment

I welcome, read, and respond to genuine comments relating to each post. If your comment isn't that save me some time by not posting it.

Popular posts from this blog

Make Disney/Pixar Style Characters with Reallusion's Character Creator and Toon Figure Bases

The Extraordinary Tourist Classic Coat outfit created using Reallusion's Toon Designer for CC3. I've talked before how I've wanted to get into 3D Disney/Pixar style character animation since I first saw the animated cutscenes for the very first Tomb Raider game back in 1996. It's why I initially bought Reallusion's iClone 3D studio app as soon as I could afford a computer that would run it. But then Reallusion released their 3D Character Creator (CC) for iClone and I wanted to create my characters with that (and I did try with Bat Storm ). But the focus of CC was realism, even with ToKoMotion's stylised body morphs . Now with Reallusion's Cartoon Designer bundle for CC3 which features two packs, Toon Figures , and Toon Hair , designing Disney/Pixar style 3D characters just got a whole lot quicker. The two packs are the bare essentials for creating Toon style characters. Five body morphs (2 male, 2 female, and one adolescent body morph that w

Create 2D Animated Characters with 3D Character Creator Tools and Artistic Filters

3D CC3 TET Character, based on my Oppa Doll Avatar, used as the base for a 2D CA4 character. One of my favorite things to do is to create characters with any type of Avatar/Character creator app. In fact the first test I usually try with these tools is, can I make an avatar of me (or at least my The Extraordinary Tourist persona). Previously I've used 2D character creators like Oppa Doll as a source of artwork for some characters I've made for Reallusion's Cartoon Animator 4 animation studio but 2D character creators are limited to... well 2D. 3D Character Creators While you may think 3D character creators have no place in creating characters for 2D animation there are quite a number of advantages including: No drawing skills required. Render characters in any style. Use an art filter or even hand trace into line art. Need to animate the character in a specific pose or angle? Render out an image of the character in the required angle and animate it in 2D. Quicker to crea

Artbreeder - Using AI created Character and Background Content in your Animations

A selection of User/AI generated images from Artbreeder. If you're looking for an endless supply of 2D character and background images for your animations then Artbreeder , an online Artificial Intelligence (AI) that generates image mash-ups you can tweak as much as you like, could be the ultimate content library. What is Artbreeder? Artbreeder is free to use though there are various paid plans, that give you additional features, such as higher resolution download images or more settings to play with. All images created on the site are Public Domain (CC0 License) and can be used in commercial projects. Using Artbreeder's online app you can generate head shot portraits, full body characters, landscapes, and other scenes simply by choosing two or more existing images to mash together then, using a series of sliders, to select which traits from each image you wish to lean toward in the final image. Photo Comparison - Top is my original uploaded photo. Bottom is Artbreeder's ap

Review: CrazyTalk Animator 3 vs Moho Studio Pro 12

Reallusion's CrazyTalk Animator 3 or Smith Micro's Moho Studio Pro 12. Which of these 2D animation applications is right for you? Regular readers of this blog will know I'm a strong supporter, and fairly proficient user of CrazyTalk Animator since version 1. It's a great piece of software for producing 2D animations from purchased content quickly and, with version 3, is easier than ever to create animations from your own art. Lesser known is that I first purchased Moho Studio Pro 12 (then known as Anime Studio Pro 9) back in October of 2012 and have been upgrading it to the latest version ever since because I believed in it as an application for creating great 2D animation to TV quality standard. As such, it's a much more complex application than CTA3 that I only got around to learning properly late last year. I'm still in the process of blogging my progress . Despite this I feel I've learned enough of Moho to compare it to CTA3 to help you determ

Three Image Overlay Apps. Do More with Your Reference Images While You Work

PureRef's image overlay in action with Cartoon Animator 4. One thing Cartoon Animator 4 still does not have in stage mode is the ability to onion skin previous and next frames.  For those complete animation newbies among you, onion skinning is the ability to see through the current frame to your previous and/or next keyframes so you can see the progression of your character or object's movement as you create and adjust each keyframe. Usually the previous and next frames appear lighter so your current frame remains the key focus. This prompted me to look for a tool that could overlay an image over my work to use as a reference while still allowing me to work on the app underneath the overlay. I had seen, and even used such apps in the past but it had been some time so I decided to see what was out there, preferably free and/or open source, with versions for Mac and Windows. Overlay 2 There are actually a number of apps that do nothing more than overlay an image but the only one

WeVideo - Professional, Collaborative, Online Video Editor for Free

WeVideo is a professional online, cloud, video editing and project sharing application that works right in your browser. It attempts to compete with equivalent licensed software that you can buy for your computer, such as (in my case) MAGIX Movie Edit Pro . WeVideo is free for personal use and comes with a range of paid plans that give you more features and benefits depending on your needs and how much you want to spend. Check out their video below which gives a great overview of WeVideo's service. In this review I'm going to see if I can use WeVideo to create a typical video for my main YouTube channel, etourist2 , where I mostly upload art and animation demonstration/tutorial videos. Before we start, here's a run down of what a free account offers: 1 GB storage 360p resolution 15 export minutes per month Export to Facebook, YouTube, Vimeo and Twitter 5 invites per project 390 licensed music titles With only 1GB of storage this account is clearly targe

Review: Reallusion's CrazyTalk Animator 3 - Taking a Step Back to Move Forward

GRRR Dog by TET. Can I animate  this guy in CrazyTalk Animator 3? CrazyTalk Animator 3 's bold claim is 'The One-for-all 2D Animation'. Does it deliver? Could it be your 'go to' 2D animation tool of choice? Before I explore those questions I feel a bit of backstory is necessary. I've been using Reallusion's CrazyTalk Animator since its original incarnation that promised quick and easy, 2D animation creation. An idea that was relative depending on what kind of animation you wanted to do. Since my focus has largely been on original character animation my experience with CTA is relative to that. If you wanted to create animated characters from your original artwork, quick and easy didn't really describe the time and effort involved. There was a lot of preparation and considerable time spent rigging its G1 characters.