Skip to main content

The Lazy Animator Versus Garry Pye - Comparing Character Animation Workflow in Cartoon Animator

The Lazy Animator and Garry Pye's Jane Danger.

Before you get all excited and start yelling 'Fight! Fight!' that's not what's happening here. There is no long running feud coming to a head at this moment with an 'Animation-off' (if that's even a thing?).

Garry Pye, Cartoon Animator Content Legend, and Reallusion's 2D Community Manager, recorded an excellent hour long webinar (excluding question time) called, Bring 2D Characters to Life with Cartoon Animator where he demonstrates how he goes about detail animating character faces for more dynamic performance.

Garry Pye's Bring 2D Characters to Life with Cartoon Animator Webinar.
Click to go to Garry's Webinar replay.
His demo animation, featuring his character, Jane Danger, showcases how he uses many Cartoon Animator features to breathe life into a 2D animated character.

What you'll notice from Garry's webinar is that he manually key frames almost everything. He doesn't even use Cartoon Animator's automatic lip syncing feature for close up animation.

Garry makes multiple passes through his animation's timeline, manually key framing the mouth, eyes, eye brows, pupils, mouth and face transformations and deformations, and even utilizing subtle full form deformation (FFD). He also manually key frames subtle shoulder movements.

There's nothing wrong with any of his process and the results speak for themselves. 

The Lazy Animator Workflow

However... Cartoon Animator has a bunch of time saving features Garry doesn't use a whole lot because, well, he's Garry... and Garry loves manual key framing and specifically having that level of control over his animation.

As someone who has adopted the name 'The Lazy Animator' the faster I can animate anything so it still looks at least somewhat competent the better!

For my own personal interest I decided to recreate Garry's demonstration project but animating it using my workflow. Note that the point isn't to recreate Garry's animation exactly. It is to compare the results between our two workflows.

Watch my video below. Inset is Garry's video so you can compare. There's no debate about which method produces the best results, it's Garry's all the way. However if you don't find manual key framing therapeutic, like Garry, you do have other workflow options within Cartoon Animator.

Breaking Down My Process

Editing the Viseme Mouth shapes in Cartoon Animator 5.
Once the auto lip sync is done I go through and manually
switch any Viseme mouth shapes that don't look right.
My set up is the same. Place the character and add the voice, however I do use the auto lip sync, even for close up character work. Broad strokes, it's usually pretty good. However, as Garry says, for close up work its failings do become more noticeable. 

It's still a real timesaver only manually fixing any part of the lip sync that doesn't quite match. I stick to the standard set of Viseme mouth shapes the system uses and don't use any additional mouth sprites added to the character at this point.

Next I do the body movement by finding one or two premade talk or idle motions I can apply to the timeline. Again a big timesaver. I'll fill the entire timeline with pre-made motion (stretching, looping, and even cutting and deleting sections of the motions as needed). 

On a close up shot like this I'll remove any animation that lifts the arms and hands onto the visible screen area, and I'll remove all the leg motions if the character is moving side to side too much. Beyond that I'm not too fussy about how well the body movement matches with what the character is saying. So long as it doesn't look totally out of place.

Adding expressions to the character's face using the Face Key Editor in Cartoon Animator.
Using the Face Key Editor I'll manually key frame
all my character's facial expressions from templates.
Note that this screen shot was taken after I did all my
puppet animation which is why you can see so
many key frames.
Using the Face Key Editor, on the Templates tab, I'll go through and match facial expressions to what is being said as best I can. The actual descriptions of the face templates are just a guide. Some expressions will actually fit with more than just the emotion they're grouped under. 

This is as close to manually keyframing I get but because the templates change a character's entire expression I save time not key framing individual items like eyebrows.

My final pass is to open the face puppet editor, select the eyeballs, head turn and rotation icons, then I do a quick record pass to bob the head around a little, move the iris', and add eye blinks (by clicking the left mouse button randomly, when I feel there should be an eye blink). 

I find this is the fastest way to do eye blinks. In Garry's process he gives some pointers about when to manually key frame eye blinks. Advice that I've followed on occasion in specific circumstances. Most of the time the viewer will only notice if your character never blinks, or blinks too much. So long as you have a few blinks, even double blinks, every now and then with some pupil movement, your character will look alive.

On this specific project I did one more pass to replace some of the mouth sprites with more expressive, non-Viseme mouth selections, just at the extreme points of the emotions mentioned in the dialogue. For example I added a much wider smile sprite when 'happy' is mentioned. I also tried to follow Garry's camera movement as well.

All in all I would say I spent around an hour and a half animating the character. The two longest tasks were correcting the Viseme mouth shapes, and adding the face template expressions - both manual key frame work.

Which Way Should You Work?

My workflow method is geared toward beginners looking for quick wins and people who are less concerned with the finer details of character animation.

Personally I find Garry's process too time consuming despite understanding that the more you manually key frame the faster and better you'll get. The same could be said for my workflow.

Then I asked Garry roughly how long it took him just to animate his project? He initially estimated an hour and a half, then he contacted me later with a revised estimate of an hour...

I know what you're thinking... I just said I took an hour and a half on my project using all these timesaving features of Cartoon Animator?

What can I say? Garry practices manual key framing a lot (I guess) to be that quick. For me, I can't stand manual key framing. The more I do it, the longer the breaks get between the next section of key framing, to the point I may not even finish my project. Just correcting the auto lip sync Viseme's on this project was a chore to me.

That said Garry's manual key framing approach gives you the most amount of control over how your character moves. If that's a priority for you, lean towards his workflow.

If less detail animation with good enough results is acceptable then start with my workflow and who knows, maybe you'll find yourself manually key framing more and more over time.


Popular posts from this blog

Inochi2D - Free Open Source 2D VTuber Avatar Rigging and Puppeteering Software (Part 1)

Inochi2D Creator - Free Open Source VTuber Software. If you've been looking for a way to live perform as a 2D cartoon avatar on camera, whether it be for a live stream or for pre-recorded content like educational videos, then VTuber software is a low cost (or even no cost) option worth looking into. In my previous post, How to Become a VTuber - 2D and 3D Software for Creating and Controlling Your Avatar , I took a brief look at the relatively new but completely free and open source Inochi2D  which I thought showed great potential for my own needs of creating a live performance character rig for my own TET Avatar that I use for all my promotional materials. While it is possible to live perform my character using Cartoon Animator itself, Reallusion's MotionLive2D capture system isn't great - with lip sync in particular. More importantly though, I can't exactly teach people how to use Cartoon Animator if I'm using Cartoon Animator to control my Avatar. What is Inochi2D

Wonder Unit Storyboarder - Free Storyboarding Software for People Who Can (or Can't) Draw

Wonder Unit Storyboarder.  As an independent and solo animator I'm always tempted to try and skip storyboarding my animated shorts because they're usually only single scene sketch comedy type jokes. As a result I have many unfinished projects that kind of petered out due to having no clear finishing line. Storyboarding your productions, no matter how small, gives you a step by step guide of every shot that needs to be completed (no planning shots as you animate). It also allows you to create an animatic that gives you a rough preview of the finished production. In short, you shouldn't skip storyboards as they, generally, increase the chance of the project being completed. Disclaimer - I'm Not a Fan of Storyboarder Upfront, Wonder Unit's Storyboarder  is not my preferred storyboarding software. However it's completely free, has a number of very compelling featu

Can You Learn Reallusion's Cartoon Animator 5 for Free Using Their 137 Official YouTube Video Tutorials Sorted Into a Logical Learning Order?

Or you could just buy The Lazy Animator Beginner's Guide to Cartoon Animator . While Reallusion's Cartoon Animator is one of the easiest 2D animation studios to get up and running with quickly, learning it from all of the official, free, video tutorials can be more overwhelming than helpful. With more than 137 videos totaling more than 28 and a half hours of tutorials, spread across three generations of the software (Cartoon Animator 3 through 5) it's hard to know if what you're learning is a current or legacy feature that you either need to know or can be skipped. Many of the official tutorials only teach specific features of the software and don't relate at all to previous or later tutorials. As a result there are many features either not mentioned or are hard to find. To make your learning easier, on this page, I've collected together all of the essential, official, free video tutorials and sorted them into a learning order that makes sense. Simply start at

Dollars Mocap: Full Body Webcam Motion Capture (Including Hands and Fingers) For iClone and Cartoon Animator

Even though I should be further away from the camera Dollars Mocap MONO still does a good job of  tracking my arms, hands and fingers. Ever since I wrote my series on becoming a VTuber , discovering it was possible to do full body motion capture, including hands and fingers, with just software and a webcam, I've been on the look out for any motion capture software that can bring that functionality to Cartoon Animator. Dollars Mocap is a low cost motion capture application with a free trial that I learned about through the YouTube Channel Digital Puppets  and their test video . It can record full body, upper body, arms and hands, and facial mocap from a live video source or pre-recorded video. Investigating further, I discovered not only does Dollars Mocap have a free iClone7, iClone8 character profile file download (look for it at the bottom of the main program download page), so you can use the saved motions with iClone8, they've also got a demo video for how to convert your

Five AI Generative Image to Video Tools For Animation You Can Try Free Right Now

The Emo Girl Character created by Start Animating. A I generative video isn't new but it is the next big thing in the visual imaging space as various development teams work to perfect the generated output.  Just like generating still images AI video sometimes struggles with physics, arm and hand movement, and the general structure of things. However it is getting better and, as is the catch cry of all AI development, this is the worst it will ever be, because it's improving fast. If you're an animator one current potential use of generative AI video is to animate your key frames, as opposed to generating something entirely from a text prompt. Starting with an image helps to keep your characters and art style consistent across AI generations. With that in mind I tried five, free image to video AI generators to see what their potential might be and whether they can handle cartoon style characters well. Note all but the last entry on the list do not create any sound with the

Eric W. Schwartz: Cartoonist, Animator and Amiga Die Hard

July 1992 Edition, CU Amiga Featuring Amy the Squirrel. American Cartoonist, Eric W. Schwartz , (whose unofficial Amiga Icon, Amy the Squirrel, is pictured on the July 92 edition of CU Amiga cover on the right) is my only real animation hero. Sure there are the big names like Disney , Chuck Jones , Tex Avery and even Preston Blair whose influences can all be seen in my own cartoons but Eric did what none of the others could. He showed that really great 2D computer animation was within my reach with little more than an Amiga Computer , a copy of Deluxe Paint and Moviesetter . This was at a time when computer based animation was in its infancy (outside of computer game animation) and Flash was something that lights did. There were many great Amiga artists but Eric was really the only one consistently making very funny, traditional style animations. His humor and drawing style is heavily influenced by classic Warner Brothers and Disney cartoons but he managed to build on this,

Animation Paper V5.0 Alpha 2 Pre-release

Animation Paper V5.0 Alpha 2 Pre-release. Animation Paper strives to be the best tool for digital hand drawn animation by not only recreating the traditional animator's table in a modern user interface, but also automating many of the more tedious processes so you can focus almost entirely on drawing. At the time of writing Animation Paper V5.0 is only available as an Alpha 2 Pre-release, and still does not have all of its features implemented, such as the ability to add audio (due to be part of the Alpha 3 release scheduled for the end of May 2020). Animation Paper has been completely redesigned and updated from th hand drawn animation app that was formerly known as Plastic Animation Paper (PAP) which, at the time, was easily one of the best apps for the sole purpose of creating hand drawn digital animation roughs. You can still download PAP completely free from the Animation Paper website . If you look past the extremely dated 90's interface it's still a great tool. I wr