Skip to main content

Review: Motion Den - DIY Video Intros and Slideshows

Motion Den claims to be the world's simplest video maker of intros and slideshow style animated videos. I needed an animated slide show to promote my etourist Skateboards online store, which I planned to make myself with one of the many video editing applications I have, but, after being directed to Motion Den by a spammy, completely unrelated comment on this very blog (which I've since deleted), I thought I'll give them a try.

The site is free to sign up and make videos with. Any published videos will have the Motion Den watermark. If you wish to remove this you can purchase individual videos or sign up for one of their plans, which give you a certain amount of credits each month to purchase videos with. Note that you can't actually do anything with a published free video other than view it in your account. There are no share options and you can't download it (making the watermark almost pointless).



A selection of Motion Den's Templates.
Motion Den is a template based system, meaning you choose a template, substitute your own photos and text, and you're good to go, instant, professional looking animated video. Nothing wrong with that at all. It's a good, time saving option if you can find a template that suits your needs.

At the time I signed up there were just five slideshow templates, most with music attached to creative commons licenses. Not a big issue but might be if you intend using the site for commercial projects. Quite by chance, the template I liked featured music that was licensed for commercial use.

Using Motion Den's video design is a breeze. Each editable component is clearly labeled. Just click on the element to add text or to select and/or upload a photo. Photos can be cropped to fit the template - so you don't need to do this before hand.

Motion Den's Studio. Expect to see the
'Saving Image' dialogue a lot!

One thing Motion Den isn't, is quick. At least not if you're uploading photos at the standard resolution of your typical phone camera. The actual upload seems fairly quick but, once you select the image for your project it takes much longer for the image to be saved into it (in most cases on my project, noticeably longer than the actual uploads - I wrote most of this review during the many wait times!).

The site also claims to save you more time for doing the things you love but it took me the best part of three hours to edit 23 scenes in my template. That seemed overly long compared to other solutions I've come across.

There also doesn't seem to be any way to preview your video properly to see how it's going. Then, once you hit 'Make Video', you're warned that you won't be able to make changes to the project anymore.

Personally I think the whole thing could be improved if you could bulk upload all your photos in the order you want them to appear, then just run through the template and crop, position or swap photos around. I found it frustrating constantly waiting on images to be saved into the project. (If I wasn't writing this review I would probably have given it away).

Below is the only video I've successfully processed and published to date (more on that in the footnote below). It's not the video I describe editing above, it's a one image, one text box (that had a character limit too small for my etouristskateboards.com URL) logo splash.


For me the process was certainly simple and easy - especially for the above video which took seconds to create but hours to process. On my initial 23 image video it was just way too slow with lots of waiting around. The amount of time I spent putting that together I feel wasn't that much less than how long it may have taken using a standard video editing application.

If you don't know how to edit photos into a slideshow, or don't have a quicker slideshow application available then Motion Den may be worth a look (though read my footnote first).

At the moment the site appears to be relatively new with many more templates for intros and openers than slideshows - so if you're in need of a professional looking opener for your videos this could well be worth a look.

I'm not altogether sure if signing up for a plan at anything other than the lowest level is worth it as it's unclear as to what extras you get at each level. However given you can use the site for free you can certainly spend as much time as you need evaluating how useful Motion Den will be for you.

Footnote: 


The video that I started out creating for this review ultimately failed to process. It was stuck at 5% processed for days. I tried creating several other videos just to see if it was an issue with my specific video but all got stuck at 5% processing for days. I contacted Motion Den's support team but have yet to hear anything.

A couple of weeks later I signed into my account and was met with this...

Yeah... that doesn't look good.

All my videos were marked as 'Errored' and no longer accessible. Further investigation revealed that all but one of the site's templates had been taken down. The remaining template I managed to customize and successfully process as the example video I posted above.

If you're reading this, long after I wrote it, and the site appears to be well populated with templates and working again, then my review, I believe, is a fair assessment of the process up until my videos got stuck in processing hell.

I contemplated not posting this review but I'd already invested quite a bit of time and whoever brought the site to my attention with their spammy, generic blog comment deserves the karma of a less than stellar review.

After my initial video failed to process I still needed to create my animated slide show for my skateboard shop. A Google search brought my attention to a similar site called Render Forest.

Render Forest is just like what Motion Den should have been only better in every way. I was able to make a quick, seven second video ad that looked very cool in under an hour, including processing time and purchasing a high quality download. I posted that video to my Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter accounts and have embeded it below.


Render Forest's Robot character
is a good representation of how
happy you'll be with their service.
I plan to write a more complete review of Render Forest at some point but, if you're looking for a site that will help you make intros, slideshows, music visualizations, and more using templates as a base then Render Forest is definitely a great option, and certainly better than Movie Den. You can even download your free published videos.

Comments

  1. Hey!

    Founder of MotionDen here. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, I suggest you check us out again and give us an updated review if you ever get the chance, we've made a world of improvements :)

    https://motionden.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mauricio, thanks for stopping by.

      I took a brief look at your updated site but, unfortunately, didn't notice any compelling differences to what I've already outlined in my review... other than your site appears to be up and working again, of course.

      Your service is still buggy, at least through Chrome browser. I can't seem to delete videos from my account. The delete function doesn't actually do anything once you click the delete button.

      I'd still recommend RenderForest over Motion Den. Their service is streets ahead, and their customer service is prompt, and helpful (whilst your comment is the first I've heard from MotionDen since I contacted your support 2 months ago).

      Delete
  2. I've tried a couple of the templates. It seems as though MotionDen updated and changed many of the issues noted above, except I received the same "Errored" and 5% rendered errors that the author did above, a year before my attempts. MotionDen still hasn't responded to my help request. Why would I spend money on something that I can't even get past the testing stage with, with any satisfaction?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In contrast, I've continued to use Render Forest, which is a much better service and their support is far more responsive. I've made a few videos now through Render Forest, while purchasing single videos from them is a little pricey it's worth it for the quality of the experience and final video.

      Thanks for stopping by and leaving your experience of Motion Den.

      Delete

Post a Comment

I welcome, read, and respond to genuine comments relating to each post. If your comment isn't that save me some time by not posting it.

Popular posts from this blog

Create 2D Animated Characters with 3D Character Creator Tools and Artistic Filters

3D CC3 TET Character, based on my Oppa Doll Avatar, used as the base for a 2D CA4 character. One of my favorite things to do is to create characters with any type of Avatar/Character creator app. In fact the first test I usually try with these tools is, can I make an avatar of me (or at least my The Extraordinary Tourist persona). Previously I've used 2D character creators like Oppa Doll as a source of artwork for some characters I've made for Reallusion's Cartoon Animator 4 animation studio but 2D character creators are limited to... well 2D. 3D Character Creators While you may think 3D character creators have no place in creating characters for 2D animation there are quite a number of advantages including: No drawing skills required. Render characters in any style. Use an art filter or even hand trace into line art. Need to animate the character in a specific pose or angle? Render out an image of the character in the required angle and animate it in 2D. Quicker to crea

Make Disney/Pixar Style Characters with Reallusion's Character Creator and Toon Figure Bases

The Extraordinary Tourist Classic Coat outfit created using Reallusion's Toon Designer for CC3. I've talked before how I've wanted to get into 3D Disney/Pixar style character animation since I first saw the animated cutscenes for the very first Tomb Raider game back in 1996. It's why I initially bought Reallusion's iClone 3D studio app as soon as I could afford a computer that would run it. But then Reallusion released their 3D Character Creator (CC) for iClone and I wanted to create my characters with that (and I did try with Bat Storm ). But the focus of CC was realism, even with ToKoMotion's stylised body morphs . Now with Reallusion's Cartoon Designer bundle for CC3 which features two packs, Toon Figures , and Toon Hair , designing Disney/Pixar style 3D characters just got a whole lot quicker. The two packs are the bare essentials for creating Toon style characters. Five body morphs (2 male, 2 female, and one adolescent body morph that w

Learn Moho Pro 12 Free Using SmithMicro's Own 104 Video Tutorials Sorted into a Logical Order of Progression

So you've bought Smith Micro's Moho Pro 12 along with the Moho, 10 hour, 104 Video Tutorials Add On pack so you can get learning right away... only you can't. For whatever reason, the video tutorials aren't sorted into any logical order of progression making them hard to follow. Yeah, I've been there, only I've done what Smith Micro should have done and sorted all the video tutorials into a logical order of natural progression for you. That is, each tutorial builds upon what you learned in previous videos and you won't suddenly come up against some feature you've never used before, unless that feature is what the video tutorial is about.

Three Image Overlay Apps. Do More with Your Reference Images While You Work

PureRef's image overlay in action with Cartoon Animator 4. One thing Cartoon Animator 4 still does not have in stage mode is the ability to onion skin previous and next frames.  For those complete animation newbies among you, onion skinning is the ability to see through the current frame to your previous and/or next keyframes so you can see the progression of your character or object's movement as you create and adjust each keyframe. Usually the previous and next frames appear lighter so your current frame remains the key focus. This prompted me to look for a tool that could overlay an image over my work to use as a reference while still allowing me to work on the app underneath the overlay. I had seen, and even used such apps in the past but it had been some time so I decided to see what was out there, preferably free and/or open source, with versions for Mac and Windows. Overlay 2 There are actually a number of apps that do nothing more than overlay an image but the only one

Artbreeder - Using AI created Character and Background Content in your Animations

A selection of User/AI generated images from Artbreeder. If you're looking for an endless supply of 2D character and background images for your animations then Artbreeder , an online Artificial Intelligence (AI) that generates image mash-ups you can tweak as much as you like, could be the ultimate content library. What is Artbreeder? Artbreeder is free to use though there are various paid plans, that give you additional features, such as higher resolution download images or more settings to play with. All images created on the site are Public Domain (CC0 License) and can be used in commercial projects. Using Artbreeder's online app you can generate head shot portraits, full body characters, landscapes, and other scenes simply by choosing two or more existing images to mash together then, using a series of sliders, to select which traits from each image you wish to lean toward in the final image. Photo Comparison - Top is my original uploaded photo. Bottom is Artbreeder's ap

Stylish Stick Figures for Cartoon Animator 4.2 - New Characters by TET

Stylish Stick Figures by TET. Animating stick figures is almost a right of passage for any animator who has ever made an old fashioned flipbook or discovered the free stickman animator app, Pivot Animator . There's also the hugely popular viral stick figure animation, Animator Versus Animation  and its sequels by Alan Becker that continue to inspire variations more than 12 years later. Back when Vyond was GoAnimate they had a stick figure theme that was popular site wide despite having many other themes with much more refined Saturday morning cartoon style characters. I even had my own stick figure series, Harry Chalk , on GoAnimate. Long story short, I was looking through the Reallusion Cartoon Animator Marketplace and discovered there really weren't any well designed, traditional looking stick figure characters. That's not to say there weren't any at all but I wanted something similar to GoAnimate's stick figures which included full facial features and male and

Screenlight - Prerelease Feedback for Your Animations and Videos Before Public Release

One way to give your animated productions the best chance of success is to prescreen them with a test audience before you release them publicly online or send them off to a festival etc. Big, Hollywood studios do this all the time so they can make changes that will hopefully give their movies a better chance for success, so why shouldn't you? While it may not be practical to gather an audience together, and have them sign a bunch of non disclosure agreements, for your 2-3 minute animated production, Screenlight is a free (with paid options for additional features), convenient, online app, that's a great alternative. Screenlight is actually intended to be a group productivity tool for gaining client feedback on every step of a video production but the 'free forever,'  single user, one project,basic account, is an ideal feedback tool for small, independent productions and hobby animators. Simply upload your video(s) (up to 1 Gigabyte) to your Screenlight Project, share t